Seller Cannot Forfeit Your Earnest Money Without Proving Loss: Delhi High Court — legal guide by Adv. Kanisth Manuja

If you paid token money (bayana) for a Delhi property and the deal fell through, the seller cannot simply pocket it. The Delhi High Court has held that forfeiture of earnest money is not an automatic consequence of breach: the seller must prove that the breach actually caused a legal injury or loss, and where the loss can be proved, it must be proved.

The ruling came in Shriram Pal Saini v. Shri Anil Kumar, RFA 330/2021 (neutral citation 2026:DHC:9361), decided by Justice Neena Bansal Krishna on 16 October 2026. The court upheld a refund of ₹4,15,000 to a buyer with interest at 6% per year, because the seller could not show that he had suffered any loss when the 2007 agreement to sell never became a sale deed.

At a glance

  • Case: Shriram Pal Saini v. Shri Anil Kumar, RFA 330/2021
  • Court: Delhi High Court, Justice Neena Bansal Krishna
  • Decided: 16 October 2026
  • Held: A seller cannot forfeit earnest money or advance payments automatically on the buyer’s breach. Under Sections 73 and 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, the seller must establish legal injury; where loss is capable of proof, it must be proved.
  • Result: Seller’s appeal dismissed. Refund of ₹4,15,000 with 6% interest from the date of the buyer’s legal notice upheld.

What happened in this case

In November 2007, the buyer agreed to purchase a 300 square yard plot in Village Shalimar, Delhi, for ₹30 lakh. He paid ₹2,00,000 as earnest money at the time of the agreement, and a further ₹2,15,000 in instalments over the next four years.

The sale then stalled. A third party had filed probate proceedings over the property, and until those ended and the seller obtained Letters of Administration in 2011, the sale deed could not be executed. After the impediment was removed, the buyer sent a legal notice in 2013 and filed a suit for specific performance of the agreement — or, in the alternative, double the amount he had paid, as the agreement provided that a defaulting seller would pay double the earnest money.

The trial court (Additional District Judge) dismissed the specific performance claim, holding that the buyer had not proved his readiness and financial capacity, but decreed a refund of the entire ₹4,15,000 with 6% interest per year. Only the buyer appealed, challenging the denial of specific performance. The seller argued in response that the buyer had defaulted and that the money had rightly been forfeited.

What the Delhi High Court held

Justice Neena Bansal Krishna dismissed the buyer’s appeal, but the reasoning on the refund of the money is what matters for every buyer and seller in Delhi.

1. Earnest money and advance payments are different things. The court explained the classic distinction: earnest money is given when the contract is made, to bind it; it is adjusted towards the price if the deal goes through and forfeited if the deal fails because of the buyer’s default. Money paid later towards the balance price is an advance (part-payment), which the buyer can ordinarily recover. Relying on Shree Hanuman Cotton Mills v. Tata Air Craft Ltd., (1969) 3 SCC 522, and the Supreme Court’s recent restatement in Central Bank of India v. Shanmugavelu, (2024) 6 SCC 641, the court held that here ₹2 lakh was earnest money and ₹2.15 lakh was advance.

2. Even earnest money cannot be forfeited without proof of loss. The key passage of the judgment reads:

“The forfeiture of earnest money paid under an Agreement to Sell, is not an automatic consequence of breach. Even the right of the seller to forfeit the earnest money on the default of the purchaser, as recognised in Shree Hanuman Cotton Mills (supra), is subject to Section 74. The amount named in the contract operates only as the outer limit of compensation. The party seeking to retain it must establish that legal injury has resulted from the breach, and where the loss is capable of proof, it must be proved.”

3. This agreement had no forfeiture clause at all. The only breach clause in the agreement ran one way: if the seller failed to execute the sale deed, he would pay double the earnest money. Nothing was named as payable by the buyer on his breach. The seller’s claim to keep the money therefore depended entirely on proving actual loss under Section 73 — and he proved none. In fact, he had asserted that property prices in the locality had risen manifold and that the plot remained with him.

4. The agreement was never terminated. The seller claimed the buyer had orally terminated the contract in January 2012, but there was no letter, no notice and no corroborating evidence. The court held that the agreement stood alive, so the money paid under it remained refundable.

5. The buyer’s claim for double the amount also failed. Even the sum named in a contract is only the upper limit of reasonable compensation under Section 74 (following Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA, (2015) 4 SCC 136). The buyer’s only proved loss was the deprivation of his money, which was made good by the refund with interest.

6. Specific performance failed on readiness and willingness. Because the suit was filed in 2016, the court applied Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act as it then stood, under which a buyer must plead and prove both willingness and the financial capacity to pay the balance. Self-serving statements do not discharge this burden; the buyer’s own bank statement was from after the suit was filed, and his part-payments in small instalments told against him. (Since the 2018 amendment to the Specific Relief Act, readiness and willingness is no longer a statutory bar, but courts still closely examine a buyer’s actual conduct and financial capacity.)

Is this new law?

No — and that is precisely why the ruling is useful. The Delhi High Court applied two settled Constitution-Bench-era principles of the Supreme Court: Fateh Chand v. Balkishan Das, (1964) 1 SCR 515, which held that Section 74 does not justify compensation where no legal injury exists, and Kailash Nath Associates, which held that Section 74 applies to forfeiture of money already paid and that loss is a precondition. What the judgment adds is a clear, recent, Delhi-specific application of that line to an ordinary residential plot transaction — and a reminder that the seller bears the burden of proof.

What this means for you

If you are a buyer who paid token money:

  • Read the agreement before signing. If there is a forfeiture clause, the amount named is only the outer limit of what a court may allow the seller to keep — not an automatic entitlement.
  • If the deal collapses, send a written legal notice demanding a refund and keep proof of delivery. Interest can run from the date of that notice, as it did here (6% per year from May 2013).
  • If you sue, claim the refund specifically (in the alternative to specific performance). Keep every receipt; distinguish what was earnest money and what was advance.
  • Claiming double the amount “because the agreement says so” will not succeed without proof of your own loss.

If you are a seller holding token money:

  • You cannot safely forfeit the money on your own say-so. If the loss is capable of documentary or oral proof, you must prove it.
  • If you want to end the agreement, do it in writing, with reasons, and communicate any forfeiture expressly and promptly. Silence for years, as in this case, destroys the defence.
  • If you actually suffered a loss — for example, another purchase you had arranged fell through because the buyer defaulted — preserve the documents and witnesses from day one.

How I approach these cases

Agreement-to-sell disputes turn on documents, notices and timing, not on arguments. In my practice, the first step is always to reconstruct the paper trail: the agreement, receipts, correspondence, and whether any termination or forfeiture was ever communicated in writing. The second step is to classify each payment correctly as earnest money or advance, because the route to recovery differs for each. Only then does a strategy emerge — refund suit, specific performance, or defending a forfeiture — and an honest assessment of what the court is likely to allow each side to keep. If you are facing a dispute over token money on a Delhi property, you can read my detailed guide on property disputes and how I handle them, or reach out for a consultation.

Frequently asked questions

Can a seller forfeit my token money if I back out of an agreement to sell?

Not automatically. Under Sections 73 and 74 of the Indian Contract Act, the seller must establish that your breach caused a legal injury or loss. Where the loss is capable of proof, it must actually be proved. If the seller cannot show any loss, courts direct a refund, usually with interest.

What is the difference between earnest money and advance payment?

Earnest money (bayana) is paid when the contract is signed to bind the deal; it is adjusted towards the price if the sale completes and may be forfeited if the buyer defaults — subject to proof of loss. Advance or part-payment is money paid towards the balance price; it remains part of the consideration and is ordinarily refundable if the sale does not happen.

The agreement says the seller can forfeit the amount. Is that clause final?

No. The Supreme Court in Kailash Nath Associates v. DDA held that Section 74 applies even to money already paid. The named amount operates only as the upper limit of reasonable compensation, and compensation requires proof of loss.

I paid years ago and the seller never communicated anything. Can I still recover?

Yes — delay by the seller strengthens your case. In this judgment, the court held that the agreement was never terminated because no termination or forfeiture was ever communicated in writing. You should send a written legal notice now and claim a refund with interest; limitation generally runs from when your right to sue accrues, which is fact-specific, so do not sit on it.

Can I get double the amount back if the seller defaults?

Not automatically. A “double the earnest money” clause is treated as a stipulation by way of penalty under Section 74. You must prove your actual loss, and the award cannot exceed reasonable compensation. Where your real loss is the money you paid, a refund with interest is the usual outcome.

Sources

Blog › Property & Real Estate Guide

By Adv. Kanisth Manuja, Advocate, Delhi High Court9 min readReviewed by Adv. Kanisth Manuja on

In this guide
  1. At a glance
  2. What happened in this case
  3. What the Delhi High Court held
  4. Is this new law?
  5. What this means for you
  6. How I approach these cases
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Sources
Related serviceBest Property Lawyer in Delhi →

How Advocate Kanisth Manuja handles these matters, step by step.

Need advice on your own matter?

Call or WhatsApp +91 9990856569

Adv. Kanisth Manuja

Advocate, Delhi High Court (Chamber S-307). He writes these guides to explain Delhi court procedure and current law in plain English. About him →

This guide is general legal information about the law as it stands, not legal advice on any particular matter.

Call now