
The Delhi High Court has confirmed that a senior citizen in Delhi can get a son, daughter, daughter-in-law or any legal heir evicted from their property — including ancestral property — for non-maintenance or ill-treatment, and they do not need to file a separate maintenance case first. In Punam v. Divisional Commissioner, GNCT of Delhi (2026:DHC:8543-DB), a Division Bench of Chief Justice Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya and Justice Tejas Karia upheld Rule 22(3)(1) of the Delhi Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009, and dismissed a daughter-in-law’s challenge to her eviction from her mother-in-law’s property. The judgment was delivered on 30 September 2026.
At a glance
- Case: Punam v. Divisional Commissioner, GNCT of Delhi & Ors., W.P.(C) 11683/2022, neutral citation 2026:DHC:8543-DB
- Court: Delhi High Court (Division Bench — the Chief Justice and Justice Tejas Karia)
- Decided: 30 September 2026
- Held: Rule 22(3)(1)(i) and (iv) of the 2009 Rules is valid; the District Magistrate can evict children, daughters-in-law and legal heirs from a senior citizen’s property for non-maintenance or ill-treatment, without any maintenance claim pending
- Result: The daughter-in-law’s writ petition was dismissed; the eviction order against her was upheld
What happened
A senior citizen (the mother-in-law) asked for her daughter-in-law to be evicted from her property. The District Magistrate (DM) initially refused. The Divisional Commissioner, hearing the appeal, reversed that refusal and ordered the daughter-in-law to vacate.
The daughter-in-law then went to the Delhi High Court with a writ petition. She argued two things. First, that Rule 22(3)(1) of the Delhi Rules of 2009 — the provision under which the eviction was ordered — was unconstitutional and beyond the power of the government because the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 does not itself mention eviction. Second, that as a married woman she had a right to live in the “shared household” under Section 17 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act), so she could not be evicted while that claim was pending.
What the court held
The Division Bench rejected the challenge and upheld the eviction. Its key findings:
1. The eviction rule is valid. Rule 22(3)(1)(i) lets a senior citizen or parent apply to the District Magistrate for eviction of a son, daughter or legal heir from “his property of any kind whether movable or immovable, ancestral or self-acquired”. The court held that this power flows from Section 22 (which lets the state confer duties on the DM to protect senior citizens’ life and property) and Section 32 (rule-making power) of the 2007 Act:
“If Rule 22(3)(1) provides that an eviction order can be passed by the District Magistrate on an application made to him by a senior citizen in certain circumstances, we are of the opinion that the impugned rule cannot be said to be ultra vires the Senior Citizens Act.”
2. No maintenance case is needed first. The court drew a clear line between two separate tracks. A claim for maintenance (monthly support money) goes to the Maintenance Tribunal under Sections 4 and 5 of the 2007 Act. An eviction application goes to the District Magistrate under Rule 22(3)(1), with an appeal to the Divisional Commissioner. Because the two are independent, “even if a prayer for maintenance under section 4 read with section 5 of the Senior Citizens Act… has not been made, an application under Rule 22(3)(1) of the 2009 Rules can be maintained.”
3. A daughter-in-law is covered. The court rejected the argument that Rule 22 applies only to sons and daughters, relying on earlier Delhi High Court decisions (including Shadab Khairi and Darshna) that read the rule liberally.
4. The DV Act “shared household” right is not automatic. On the facts, the daughter-in-law was a Post Graduate Teacher with a substantial income and a separate house of her own in Bahadurgarh. The court held that her claim to remain in the shared household was “not indefeasible” and had to be weighed against the senior citizen’s right “to live a normal and peaceful life”. Section 4(3) of the 2007 Act requires children to maintain their parents so that the parents can lead a normal life — and the eviction order was upheld.
The court also noted that the Supreme Court has already held — in S. Vanitha v. Deputy Commissioner, Samtola Devi, Ravi Kant Gupta and Rajeswar Prasad Roy v. State of Bihar (30 January 2025) — that authorities under the Senior Citizens Act can order eviction where it is necessary to protect the senior citizen.
Is this new law?
Not entirely new, but it settles two practical questions in Delhi. First, the constitutionality of Delhi’s own eviction procedure (Rule 22(3)(1)) is now settled by a Division Bench — earlier conflicting views from the Punjab and Haryana High Court were expressly noted to no longer be good law. Second, it confirms that an eviction application can be filed on its own, without waiting for or joining a maintenance case, and that daughters-in-law can be evicted where the circumstances justify it.
What this means for you
If you are a senior citizen (or helping an elderly parent):
- You can apply to the District Magistrate (Deputy Commissioner) of your district for eviction of a son, daughter, daughter-in-law or legal heir who is not maintaining you or is ill-treating you — from self-acquired or ancestral property.
- You do not need to file a maintenance case first. The eviction route (DM → appeal to the Divisional Commissioner) is separate from the maintenance route (Maintenance Tribunal under Sections 4–5). You can use either or both.
- Keep your documents ready: proof of title or ownership of the property, your age proof, and whatever evidence you have of non-maintenance or ill-treatment (messages, witnesses, medical records, bank statements showing no support).
- Expect the DM to forward the matter to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate for verification of title and facts, followed by a show-cause notice to the occupants before any eviction order.
If you are the son, daughter or daughter-in-law living in the property:
- An ownership dispute or a pending DV Act residence claim will not automatically protect you if the property belongs to the senior citizen and you have your own income and accommodation.
- The court looks at the overall picture — your income, whether you have another place to live, and the senior citizen’s need to live peacefully.
These cases turn heavily on documents and procedure — the difference between a dismissed application and an eviction order is usually how well the file is prepared at the DM stage and on appeal.
How I approach these cases
In my practice, I first establish the property record and the family facts on paper — title documents, the senior citizen’s status, and a clear chronology of non-maintenance or ill-treatment with supporting evidence. I then choose the right forum for the goal: a Rule 22(3)(1) application before the District Magistrate where the immediate need is to recover the property, and a Section 4/5 application before the Maintenance Tribunal where regular financial support is the priority. On the defence side, the answer is equally document-driven — income, alternative accommodation, and the senior citizen’s own conduct all matter. In either case, acting early, before positions harden and counter-complaints begin, makes a real difference. If you are dealing with a senior-citizen eviction or maintenance matter in Delhi, you can read more about how I handle family, matrimonial and maintenance disputes, or get in touch through the contact options on this page.
Frequently asked questions
Can parents in Delhi evict their son from a self-acquired house?
Yes. Rule 22(3)(1)(i) of the Delhi Rules of 2009 expressly covers property “whether movable or immovable, ancestral or self-acquired”. The Delhi High Court has upheld this provision as valid, so both self-acquired and ancestral property qualify.
Do parents have to file a maintenance case before seeking eviction?
No. The High Court has clarified that eviction proceedings before the District Magistrate under Rule 22(3)(1) are independent of maintenance proceedings before the Tribunal under Sections 4 and 5 of the 2007 Act. An eviction application can be filed even if no maintenance claim has been made.
Can a daughter-in-law be evicted from the mother-in-law’s property?
Yes, in appropriate circumstances. The Delhi High Court has held that the rule cannot be read narrowly to exclude daughters-in-law. However, the outcome depends on the facts — in this case the daughter-in-law had her own income and a separate house, and the court found her shared-household claim was not indefeasible.
Does the Domestic Violence Act protect a woman from such an eviction?
Section 17 of the DV Act gives a woman the right to reside in the shared household, but the Delhi High Court has held this right is not automatic or indefeasible. Where the property belongs to a senior citizen who is entitled to live peacefully, and the claimant has independent income and alternative accommodation, eviction can still be ordered.
What happens if the District Magistrate refuses to order eviction?
The senior citizen can appeal to the Divisional Commissioner. In this very case, the DM had initially refused eviction and the Divisional Commissioner reversed that decision on appeal — and the High Court upheld the Commissioner’s order.
Who decides maintenance for parents — the DM or a court?
Maintenance (monthly financial support) is decided by the Maintenance Tribunal constituted under Section 7 of the Senior Citizens Act, on an application under Sections 4 and 5. Eviction is decided by the District Magistrate under Rule 22(3)(1), with an appeal to the Divisional Commissioner. The two tracks are separate.
Sources
Blog › Family & Matrimonial Guide
How Advocate Kanisth Manuja handles these matters, step by step.
More guides
This guide is general legal information about the law as it stands, not legal advice on any particular matter.


