
Legal News › Criminal Law Explained
In Arun alias Deepak v. State of U.P., the Supreme Court called a murder probe slipshod and told Uttar Pradesh to pay a man acquitted after six years in jail.
Key points
- As reported, the Supreme Court on 26 October 2026 ordered Uttar Pradesh to pay Rs 6 lakh to a man who spent about six years in jail before he was acquitted.
- The Court called the investigation slipshod. The man was not named in the FIR and the case rested on CCTV footage and a co-accused’s confession.
- The money must be paid within one month. Late payment carries 18% yearly interest.
- Acquittal alone does not bring compensation. This order was made on its own facts, so a wrongly jailed person should speak to a lawyer early.

What happened?
A man in Agra district, Uttar Pradesh, was arrested in November 2019. He was accused of kidnapping and killing another man, as per the FIR at Achhnera police station.
The case was charged under the old Indian Penal Code (sections 364, 302 and 201, as reported). That law was in force in 2019.
He stayed in jail as an undertrial (a person in jail while the trial is still on) for about six years. In March 2026 the Supreme Court looked at his bail plea and told the trial court to finish the trial in three months.
The trial court then acquitted him (found him not guilty). The Supreme Court asked for that judgment and passed its order on 26 October 2026.
What did the Supreme Court say?
The bench of Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran was strongly critical of the police probe.
The Court said it could not but “deprecate” (strongly disapprove of) the way the investigation was done, as reported.
It also said the State “cannot shirk” its duty to protect its citizens.
So it ordered Uttar Pradesh to pay the man Rs 6 lakh. The Court itself said this was small next to the years he lost.
Also read | Other Cases Pending Against You? Delhi High Court Says That Alone Cannot Stop Bail: What the Law Says
Why was the investigation criticised?
According to the reports, the Court pointed to many gaps.
The man was not named in the FIR. He was not named in the first statement of the complainant either.
He was linked to the crime through CCTV footage and a confession by a co-accused. That co-accused died during the trial, and another accused was absconding.
The CCTV material had no certificate that the law needs for electronic evidence. The bones found were not proved to be those of the missing man. The cause of death was not shown, and DNA results were not placed before the court.
Only six witnesses were examined.
What must UP do now?
Uttar Pradesh must pay Rs 6 lakh within one month. If it pays late, it must add 18% interest a year.
The Court sent a copy of the order to the state Director General of Police and the Home Secretary. It said the state police should train its officers in how to investigate.
Which law applies, and could he have got bail earlier?
Two bail rules in the new law (BNSS, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) are worth knowing.
Section 483 lets the High Court or Sessions Court grant bail to a person who is in custody. This is the usual route when a lower court refuses.
Section 479 says an undertrial must be released once he has served part of the maximum sentence. But it does not cover offences that carry death or life imprisonment. A murder charge falls outside it.
That is why long custody can still happen in serious cases. A bail plea has to be argued case by case.
This article does not say what any court will do in another case. It reports what the Supreme Court did here.
Sections involved
What happens next in a case like this?
The order ends this man’s claim for money. For others, the path is longer and not certain.
The State was ordered to pay even though, as reported, no one had asked for compensation in the usual way.
What happens next
- 1FIR and arrestFIR in 2019; the accused is in custody from 14 November 2019.
- 2Bail pleaSupreme Court notes long custody and orders the trial to end in three months (March 2026).
- 3AcquittalTrial court finds the case not proved and acquits him.
- 4Supreme Court orderRs 6 lakh within one month, 18% interest if late (26 October 2026).
- 5PaymentUP government pays; police training and copy to DGP and Home Secretary.
Does every acquitted person get compensation?
No. An acquittal by itself does not bring money. Courts look at the facts: how long the person was held, how weak the case was and how the police behaved.
This order shows that a court can award money when the probe is badly done. It does not create a fixed rate. Rs 6 lakh is what the bench set here.
If a family member is held as an undertrial, ask:
- Is the person named in the FIR, or only linked later?
- What is the main evidence: a witness, recovery, CCTV or a co-accused’s statement?
- Has a bail plea been filed in the Sessions Court and then the High Court?
- How many months or years has the person been in custody?
- Are all papers, dates and orders kept in one file?
If this happens to you
- Get the FIR and charge papers. Ask for certified copies from the court. Read who is named and what evidence is listed.
- File for bail early. If the Sessions Court refuses, a bail petition can go to the High Court. See bail lawyer in Delhi.
- Push for a speedy trial. A long delay is a good ground to put before the court. Keep a list of every date and adjournment.
- Keep proof of the custody period. Jail records and release papers will matter if you later seek compensation.
- After an acquittal, take legal advice. A claim for compensation depends on the facts and is not automatic. See criminal law and Delhi High Court advocate.
Case at a glance
- Court
- Supreme Court of India (Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran)
- Case
- Arun alias Deepak v. State of U.P., SLP (Crl.) 4859 of 2026, as reported
- Where
- Achhnera police station, Agra, Uttar Pradesh (FIR 367 of 2019)
- Custody
- About six years as an undertrial, from 14 November 2019
- Order
- Rs 6 lakh within one month; 18% yearly interest if late (26 October 2026)
Related news
Sources
- Law Trend: 'Educate Police Officers In The Process Of Investigation': Supreme Court Orders UP To Pay Rs 6 Lakh To Man Acquitted After Six Years In Jail (26 October 2026)
- LawChakra: Supreme Court Orders Rs 6 Lakh Compensation To Man Acquitted After Six Years As Undertrial (26 October 2026)
- Mangalorean.com (PTI): SC slams 'slipshod investigation', orders UP to pay Rs 6 lakh to man acquitted after six years as undertrial (26 October 2026)
More legal news
This explainer is general legal information based on news reports and the text of the law. It is not legal advice on any particular case, and it does not say that any person has committed an offence; allegations are decided by the courts.

