
A widowed daughter-in-law living in her father-in-law’s flat cannot be thrown out simply because he owns it. In Late Raj Kumar @ Babbal v. Attar Singh (RFA 778/2023, 2026:DHC:9028), decided on 12 October 2026, the Delhi High Court upheld the owner’s decree for possession but held that it can be executed only after he arranges suitable alternate accommodation for her, or pays her Rs 15,000 a month as rent. The court also set aside the Rs 10,000 a month damages the trial court had ordered the family to pay.
At a glance
- Case: Late Raj Kumar @ Babbal (deceased) through legal representatives v. Attar Singh, RFA 778/2023
- Court and bench: Delhi High Court, Justice Neena Bansal Krishna
- Decided: 12 October 2026 (reserved on 12 August 2026)
- Held: the flat was the widow’s “shared household”; her right to stay did not end with her husband’s death; a father-in-law’s duty to maintain a widowed daughter-in-law includes residence
- Result: appeal partly allowed; possession decree upheld but executable only after alternate accommodation or Rs 15,000 a month rent; damages set aside
What happened
The father-in-law owned a DDA flat in Paschim Vihar, Delhi. After a legal notice in 2012, he sued his son for possession and damages. The son died in 2015 while the suit was pending, and his widow and two daughters were brought on record. On 22 May 2023 the Additional District Judge ordered them to hand over vacant possession and to pay Rs 10,000 a month as damages from 1 January 2013. The widow and her daughters appealed to the High Court.
By the time of the judgment the father-in-law was living in another flat in the same colony with his younger son, while the widow had lived in the suit flat with her daughters for over twenty years. The court noted that nothing on record showed any earnings or property of her own, or any estate left by her husband.
What the court held
1. The flat was her “shared household.” Section 2(s) of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 covers a household where the woman lived in a domestic relationship, whether or not she or her husband has any title. The court said her husband’s death “does not ipso facto extinguish the character of the premises as the shared household of the wife.”
2. The owner can still sue for possession. Relying on Satish Chander Ahuja v. Sneha Ahuja (2021) 1 SCC 414, the court repeated that the right of residence is not indefeasible and that a civil suit for possession is a procedure established by law.
3. But a father-in-law has a duty of maintenance. Section 19 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 says a Hindu wife is entitled to be maintained after her husband’s death by her father-in-law, to the extent she cannot maintain herself from her own earnings or property. Section 3(b) defines maintenance to include “residence.” The court concluded that the father-in-law “has an obligation to maintain Appellant No. 1, which includes providing her a residence.”
4. The relief must be balanced. Following Ravneet Kaur v. Prithpal Singh Dhingra (Delhi High Court, 2022), where the Supreme Court declined to interfere, the court said it must “mould the relief so that the woman is not deprived of shelter.” Para 150 of the judgment directs that the decree is executable only after the owner “first secures suitable alternate accommodation” in the same or a nearby locality, or pays Rs 15,000 a month, and that the Executing Court must ensure this before the decree is given effect to.
Is this new law?
No statute changed. The judgment joins two existing laws: the shared-household protection of the Domestic Violence Act and the maintenance duty in the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act. Earlier Delhi High Court decisions have gone the other way where the facts differed, for example where the owner was a senior citizen needing the property, so each case turns on its facts. This is a single-judge decision on first appeal.
What it means for you
If you are a widowed daughter-in-law
- Following Prabha Tyagi v. Kamlesh Devi (2022) 8 SCC 90, the right of residence under section 17 of the Domestic Violence Act does not depend on first establishing an act of domestic violence. You must still raise it in the case and show that you lived in the house in a domestic relationship.
- Be ready to show that you cannot maintain yourself: income, property, and what your husband left.
- The protection is a right to be rehoused or paid rent, not a right to stay in the owner’s flat for ever.
If you are the owner (father-in-law)
- Your title and your right to a possession decree remain.
- Before the decree can be executed, expect to be asked to provide a comparable home nearby, or rent. Rs 15,000 was fixed on the facts of this Delhi locality and is not a fixed rate.
- Mesne profits (damages for occupation) need evidence of the letting value; the court rejected an award based only on the nature of the locality.
Practical checklist
- Keep proof of residence in the flat: ration card, Aadhaar, electricity and gas bills, school records of the children.
- Collect proof of the family’s finances: your income, bank statements, and any property or estate your husband left.
- Read every notice and plaint carefully: reply within the time allowed in the summons, and raise the shared-household and maintenance pleas in the written statement.
- If you are the owner, keep the title documents and any evidence of the letting value of the flat, since damages need proof and not an estimate.
- Consider a written settlement on alternate housing or rent; the court itself looked for a mechanism that protects both sides.
How I approach these cases
In a family property dispute I first sort out who owns the property and who is entitled to live in it, then the family relationship and the maintenance position. I gather the title documents, proof of residence, and income details before choosing between a defence in the possession suit, a maintenance claim and a settlement. I do not promise outcomes or timelines. For the wider picture, see my family and matrimonial lawyer page; for ownership and possession suits, my property lawyer page.
Frequently asked questions
Does a widow lose her right to live in her in-laws’ house when her husband dies?
Not automatically. This judgment holds that the death of the husband does not by itself end the character of the house as her shared household. The owner can still sue to recover possession.
Can a father-in-law evict his widowed daughter-in-law?
He can obtain a decree for possession, but in this case it could be executed only after he secured alternate accommodation for her or paid rent of Rs 15,000 a month.
Which law makes a father-in-law maintain a widowed daughter-in-law?
Section 19 of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, where she cannot maintain herself from her own earnings or property or from her husband’s estate, or her parents or children.
Does maintenance include a place to live?
Yes. Section 3(b) of the Act defines maintenance to include provision for residence, along with food, clothing, education and medical care.
Is Rs 15,000 a month the rule for all such cases?
No. It was the figure chosen for this Paschim Vihar flat. Another court may fix a different amount depending on the locality and facts.
Does the widow have to file a Domestic Violence Act case first?
The judgment, following Prabha Tyagi (2022) 8 SCC 90, says the right of residence under section 17 does not depend on first establishing domestic violence. It still has to be raised and proved in the proceedings.
Sources
Blog › Family & Matrimonial Guide
How Advocate Kanisth Manuja handles these matters, step by step.
More guides
This guide is general legal information about the law as it stands, not legal advice on any particular matter.


