
The Delhi High Court has held that a mother, as the natural guardian of her children, has a better claim to their custody than the grandparents unless she is shown to be unfit, incapable or negligent. In Ram Kumar v. Smt. Asha Kataria (MAT.APP.(F.C.) 389/2026, decided on 13 October 2026), a Division Bench dismissed a paternal grandfather’s appeal for custody of his two grandchildren after their father’s death. It matters to any family in Delhi where a parent has died and the extended family wants the children.
At a glance
- Case: Ram Kumar v. Smt. Asha Kataria, MAT.APP.(F.C.) 389/2026 (no neutral citation yet)
- Court and bench: Delhi High Court, Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar
- Date of decision: 13 October 2026
- Appeal under: Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, against a Family Court judgment of 15 May 2026 in a custody petition under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890
- Held: the natural guardian (here the mother) has a superior claim over grandparents unless she is unfit, incapable or negligent; the children’s own wishes carry weight
- Result: appeal dismissed; the grandfather may apply to the Family Court for visitation
What happened
The appellant is the paternal grandfather. His son died on 1 December 2016, and the two children (a girl born in 2008 and a boy born in 2010) stayed with their mother. The grandfather went to the Family Court under the Guardians and Wards Act asking for their custody. He said the mother was a working woman who could not look after both children, that she was not giving them a proper atmosphere, and that the grandparents could give a better and more congenial home. He also said she was not letting the children meet the grandparents.
The mother did not file a written statement, so her right to file one was struck off. The Family Court nevertheless spoke to the children. By its order of 5 March 2025 it noted that they could barely recognise their grandfather and did not want any contact with him. It refused custody. The grandfather appealed.
What the court held
The High Court gave these reasons:
- The children’s views count. They were almost 18 and 15 when the Family Court spoke to them. The Bench said it “cannot be said that the children at this age have been tutored” and that they “have their own independent mind”. The daughter became an adult in July 2026.
- No fault shown in the mother. There was “nothing on record which would indicate that the mother is not bringing up the children properly”. She is an Income-Tax Officer, financially independent, with her own accommodation.
- Allegations about the marriage were beside the point. Whether the mother had been cruel to the late husband “is not a matter which has to be discussed or decided” in a custody case under the Guardians and Wards Act.
- The natural guardian comes first. The Bench said it is “well settled that the natural guardian has a superior claim than grandparents”, and that the mother’s right “takes precedence over others, unless and until the Court is satisfied that the mother is unfit, incapable or has been negligent”. In its words, “the respondent/mother cannot be deprived of the children and the children cannot be deprived of their mother.”
The Bench relied on Vivek Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of U.P., (2025) 4 SCC 342, where the Supreme Court said that grandparents could not have a better claim than the father, who was the natural guardian, while the welfare of the child remained the paramount consideration.
Visitation: what the court left open
The Bench did not shut the door on the grandparents. It said the adult granddaughter is free to visit them if she wishes, and that a court cannot force a grandchild to meet them or stop her. For the younger child, the grandfather may apply to the Family Court for visitation rights, which “shall be considered by the Family Court on its own merits after eliciting the willingness of the grandchildren.”
Is this new law?
Not really. It applies a settled approach. Under the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, the father and then the mother are the natural guardians of a minor. In Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India (AIR 1999 SC 1149) the Supreme Court read the word “after” in section 6(a) so that a mother is not a guardian only once the father has died. What the Delhi High Court adds is a clear, recent statement that, with a surviving mother who is caring for the children, grandparents must show real unfitness or neglect, not just a better lifestyle. This is a Division Bench judgment on its own facts, with a surviving mother and children old enough to say what they want. It should not be read as deciding every custody dispute.
What this means for you
If you are a mother after a husband’s death
- Keep records of how the children are being looked after: school, medical care, where they live and who supports them.
- Respond to the court notice and file your written statement on time. In this case the mother’s right to file one was struck off, so do not leave a notice unanswered.
- Do not block contact out of anger. Courts weigh the children’s own wishes, but a reasonable approach to visits helps.
If you are a grandparent
- A claim that you can provide a better home is not enough when the mother is fit and the children live with her.
- If your real aim is to stay in touch, ask for visitation. Custody and visitation are different reliefs.
- Older children are asked what they want. Their answer will matter.
- Do not bring up unrelated disputes about the marriage unless they bear on the children’s welfare.
For both sides
- Custody petitions in Delhi go to the Family Court, and an appeal lies to the High Court under section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984. File an appeal within the limitation period; the delay of 85 days in this appeal had to be condoned by the Court.
How I approach these cases
In my practice I start with the child’s welfare, because that is what the court decides on. I list what is on record about schooling, health, home and the child’s wishes, and separate it from disputes about the marriage that do not bear on custody. Where a parent and relatives disagree, I look at whether a visitation arrangement can settle the matter before a full contest. Each matter is judged on its own facts, and I make no promise about the result. For divorce, custody and maintenance matters, see my page on the best divorce lawyer in Delhi.
Frequently asked questions
Can grandparents get custody of grandchildren in Delhi?
They can apply under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, but the court decides on the welfare of the child. Where a fit parent is looking after the children, the Delhi High Court has said the parent’s claim comes first.
Does a working mother lose custody because she works?
No. In this case the grandfather argued that the mother’s job meant she could not look after the children, and the Court found nothing to show she was not bringing them up properly.
Do children’s wishes matter in a custody case?
Yes. The Family Court spoke to the children, and the High Court gave weight to their wish to stay with their mother because they were old enough to think independently.
Can grandparents get visitation instead?
The High Court said the grandfather may apply to the Family Court for visitation rights, which will be decided on merits after finding out whether the grandchildren are willing.
Where is the appeal heard if the Family Court refuses custody?
An appeal against a Family Court judgment lies to the High Court under section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984.
Sources
- Judgment text, Delhi High Court, MAT.APP.(F.C.) 389/2026, 13 October 2026: delhihighcourt.nic.in
- LiveLaw report: Mother’s Right To Child Custody Takes Precedence Over Grandparents Unless She Is Unfit
- Githa Hariharan v. Reserve Bank of India, AIR 1999 SC 1149, as discussed in Cornell Law School’s Gender Justice resource
This post is general information on a reported judgment, not legal advice for your situation.
Blog › Family & Matrimonial Guide
How Advocate Kanisth Manuja handles these matters, step by step.
More guides
This guide is general legal information about the law as it stands, not legal advice on any particular matter.


